Keywords: #ChaTaeHyun #KongHyoJin #KimSooHyun #차태현 #김수현 #공효진 #Producers #프로듀사
Hello. Welcome to “Producers… What is this?” lecture about a new Korean Drama. My name is Prof. AKIA to those who are new. I talk and review Korean Dramas. Today, it is all about the new Korean drama “Producers/ 프로듀사”(2015) after watching the first 2 episodes.
More
accurately, it is “Producaaaaa”.
It is a Korean word pun.
Introduction
There
have been a few Korean dramas
about the entertainment
industry in Korea. Not many but some
interesting few exists. Examples would be “King of Drama” (2012), “The World
That They Live In” (2008), and “On Air” (2008).
If you
think about it, all of these dramas are very different in tone. “King of Drama” (2012) is
basically an edgy “dramedy” with an anti-hero at the center. “On Air” (2008) is more your traditional
trendy ensemble romance drama with slight hints of seriousness. “The World That
They Live In” (2008) is a dry drama about the working stiffs within the
industry.
Where
does Producers (2015) fall into you ask?
This
is somewhat of a difficult question to answer from only watching the first 2
episodes as there have been some important changes from one to another.
Generally, Producers (2015) falls more into the “The
World That They Live In” (2008) camp of dry drama which is reinforced
by the whole “Mockumentary” technique being used.
We’ll
get to that whole thing later!
However,
at the same time, it also has comedy and romance elements of the other camps
which become more prominent in episode 2.
So….
It’s complicated!
The Plot
Not
only is the definition of the show complicated but describing the basic plot is also complicated as the show feels scattered
and without a strong narrative focus.
This in
itself is not totally a bad thing.
If I
was asked to give an elevator pitch about this show, I would say that it is a mash
up of two work place shows: the
American TV sitcom “The Office”
(2005-2013) and the Korean drama “Misaeng”
(2014)
From
this image, you can infer that Producers (2015) is more of an ensemble show. This means that there is
not exactly a main protagonist as all 4 main
characters are the show’s protagonists.
However, there is an “audience stand-in”, character who helps us enter the professional and personal world of the show. Producers’ “audience stand-in”, is Kim Soo-Hyun’s (김수현) character.
However, there is an “audience stand-in”, character who helps us enter the professional and personal world of the show. Producers’ “audience stand-in”, is Kim Soo-Hyun’s (김수현) character.
Whether
an “audience stand-in” character is needed for a “Mockumentary” style
show is debatable. Whether the execution of the “audience stand-in”
character was done well in Producers (2015) is far less up in the
air.
It was
not well handled!
What a
moran!
We call
his character in the Korean army the torturer!
Basically
because he get everyone in trouble.
The
show starts with Kim Soo-Hyun’s (김수현) character starting his first
day as the new PD at a Broadcasting company’s variety show department. The term “PD” is used fast and loose in this
show which oddly reflects the industry reality correctly.
PD= Producer + Director
In any
case, back to the plot.
Then
the show splits focus between him as an idiot newbie and 3 other disparate main
cast members played by Cha Tae-Hyun / 차태, Kong Hyo-Jin /공효진,
and IU doing their own mundane choirs of, running shows, following bureaucratic and being
a Kpop star in
the case of IU’s character!
The “Mockumentary” technique
With
the rise of “reality” TV and “Found footage” Movies, the “Mockumentary” technique gained popularity.
In TV, the popular examples of this is “The Office” (2005-2013) and “Modern
Family” (2009-).
However,
the two are actually very different in their levels of adherence to the technique
with the “The Office” (2005-2013) being relatively more strict than “Modern
Family” (2009-). The “Mockumentary” technique uses two general techniques with one
being the “Act like that camera is not in the
room” technique
and the other being the “Confessional” interview technique. “Modern
Family” (2009-) only really uses the latter.
In the
case of “Producers” (2015), it uses both angles of
the “Mockumentary” technique in the vein of “The Office” (2005-2013). And I am
not sure it really works.
I think
the show knows it too since the second episode has far less of it.
Or, and
more likely, it was too much of a haste.
The “Mockumentary”
technique is a more stylized approach to “4th
wall breaking”. It lets the show directly talk to the
audience while still pretending not to. It is not a technique to be used “Willy-nilly”
as it does alters the relationship between the audience and the art being observed.
If used poorly, it could damage the suspension of disbelief the audience needs.
Definition of Breaking
the Fourth Wall
Breaking the fourth wall is when a character acknowledges
their fictionality, by either indirectly or directly addressing the audience.
Alternatively, they may interact with their creator (the author of the book,
the director of the movie, the artist of the comic book, etc.).
Excerpt
from tvtropes.org
With “Producers” (2015), the show uses both angles of the “Mockumentary” technique. In other
words, it has a “in world fictional” camera chasing the characters around
filming an actual “in world”
documentary for some reason in addition to inserting “confessional” interview scenes throughout
the show.
In
other words, they are going in deep!
You can more easily get away with just interview inserts.
Was it Worth it?
The problem is that the show takes the “Willy-nilly” direction to this as they.
There is have no real strict rule and logic to how the a “in world” camera man is used. For example, the camera man is
frequently at locations where he/she should not be at logically.
The
execution is rather clunky.
Also,
the show also uses standard Korean drama “behind
the 4th wall” scenes which rather mixes up the show with 3 types
of technique all jumbled together. If the “Mockumentary” technique was an infrequent gimmick, you could just skim it over.
However, there is a lot of it in the first episode.
It is a relief that the second episodes lets up!
At
this point, you have to ask yourself the following question. Is it at least
worth going through this whole haste at the end?
Mmmmm…..?
.
.
.
.
.
Meh?
I’m
not sure at this point. It is at least refreshing that a Korean drama is trying
new things. It could also provide a more realistic feel to the show and let the
writer provide more insight into the characters and the industry setting. However, considering
how the show is utilizing it, the whole “Mockumentary”
thing feels more like a gimmick that could get old fast.
I mean
really fast!
It seems
to be just a device to deliver jokes while pretending to be serious
at the same time. You have the “in world”
camera man scene set up a joke while the “Confessional” interview scene delivers the
punch line.
You do
not get much character insight through them.
This
is repeated multiple times during the first episodes and not only did most of
the jokes not really land but it got repetitive fast. Ultimately, the show is
no more insightful than your standard Korean drama romantic comedy which is the
key to answering the question of whether it was worth it.
It is not!
However, this
does not mean the show is terrible.
Until
this point, I talked mostly about the whole technical weird stuff the show is
trying out. This is because the first two episodes I saw especially the first
one were just setup filled with a series of exposition scenes and monologues. Since
“Producers”
(2015) is basically a dry “slice of life“ work place ensemble show, it needs to
pick up momentum before actually getting interesting.
.
So, do not expect a riveting hour of TV!
However, there are some amusing stuff in there.
Learning
about the behind the scenes stuff is interesting albeit only a little bit
because the coverage is too light. In comparison, watching the “characters” going
about their mundane day has more potential. How much is all on the actors’
shoulders. Can they hold the attention of the audience even if they are just
reading a phone book?
They will need
that ability!
In
this regard, “Producers” (2015) is somewhat mixed. Cha
Tae-Hyun / 차태현and Kong Hyo-Jin /공효진are interesting enough actors to handle just being
given exposition and monologues. Even the supporting actors are decent overall
just shuffling around and spouting out “office speak”.
The
problem is with Kim Soo-Hyun / 김수현and
IU / 아이유.
They simply cannot do the same. They are extremely flat in the two episodes I’ve
seen as if it was their first time at this job. However, I cannot totally blame the two because they
are actually given less to do than either Cha
Tae-Hyun / 차태현and Kong Hyo-Jin /공효진.
Their characters are extremely underwritten especially IU’s role.
Like
many actors of their generation, these two have very little range in terms of
their acting. They can basically do one thing or two decently. That is the
reason they got to be on screen, In the case of “Producers” (2015), what the show wants is not what they have.
Conclusion
Will I
keep watching the show?
I am
not sure at the moment. Objectively, “Producers” (2015) is not a terrible show
relative to most recent Korean dramas. I enjoyed it more than the first week of
“Misaeng” (2014). This means I was able to get through the first two episodes.
A lot of shows
cannot claim the same!
However,
I am biased against “Misaeng” because I hated Si-wan’s (시완)
character in that show. Producers (2015) also has a terrible character played
by Kim Soo-Hyun / 김수현.
He is passive and a huge moron to the degree that I sometimes think he is
mentally retarded on the level of “Forrest Gump” (1994). IU’s character does
not help the situation but there is barely a character there anyway.
Thankfully,
Kim Soo-Hyun’s (김수현) character is just one of many here.
I think
I can work with that…
However, I still made it through and the second
episode, which seems to shift towards a more of standard Korean drama compared
to the first episode, was a slight improvement. The only thing I can say at the
moment is that there is some potential here.
Not much but not too bad also…
Overall,
I give the first 2 episodes of the new Korean drama a B- grade.
Score:
B- or 6/10
Thanks for coming to my lecture about the first
2 episodes of , “Producers” (2015).
Please comment below and share the word to your
friends.
Class
dismissed!
This was Prof. AKIA talking.
Thank you for reading this article! SHARE Them via social Media!!!!!!!!!
Ex-Girlfriend Club (2015) First Impressions |
![]() |
Hwajung / Splendid Politics (2015) First Impressions |
![]() |
Hwajung 화정(2015): Basic History you need to know |
![]() |
Queen's Flower (2015) First 4 week Review |
![]() |
The Girl Who Sees Smells (2015) First Impressions: |
![]() |
Seonam Girls High School Detectives Review |
![]() |
Jingbirok 징비록 (2015) First Impressions |
Click below to subscribe for upto date reviews and news
Thanks for reading this article. Please comment below and you can do it as a guest.
Also, it would be appreciated if you donate what you can towards the site. Thank.
Created by AKIA Talking
Email: akoreaninamerica@outlook.com
Twitter: https://twitter.com/AKorAmerica
FaceBook: http://www.facebook.com/aKoreanInAmerica
Blog Feed: http://feeds.feedburner.com/AKoreanInAmerica
Podcast List: http://www.akiatalking.com/search/label/podcastKorean Movie Blog: http://www.kmovietalk.com/
All of the pictures and videos here are used for criticism and references purposes. They are not mine. Only the article itself is my property.
0 comments:
Post a Comment